
I’ve been polling all kinds of random people for marital advice. I figure it’s always a good idea. If I get crappy advice, I can often tell right away – either it sets off spidey-senses, I can detect a lack of general credibility or I can just tell that’s it’s obviously not working for the person dispensing the advice.
One piece of advice I get all the time, and have received from people who can be described as “happy and well-adjusted” as well as “clearly suffering” is:
You have to learn that people don’t change. When you give up on that, you’ll be happy.
Now I’ve heard it a few different ways. I’ve heard “You can’t change a person.” I’ve heard “People never change.” I’ve heard “You can’t wait around for people to change.” In order, I think those statements are true, false, true.
I know people change. Really change. In the important ways. I have personally witnessed several people experience real changes that have lasted years. They were one way (prone to anger, self-destructive, addicted to something), and now they are another. I have also know people who changed only for a time.
I’ve known people for whom change came as a long, difficult struggle, and I’ve known those who came out of some intense experience different than they were before.
But the real question I’m interested in here is this, “Within the context of a marriage, can . . . should people change?”
If your spouse has some habit that drives you nuts, is it okay for you to ask him to kick it? If she doesn’t see eye-to-eye with you on some question of parenthood or money-management or politics, can you ask her to see it your way?
It’s easy to feel like those are two totally different questions. But are they really so different to the person being asked to change?
“Stop smoking!”
“Vote Republican!”
Sometimes I wonder if those feel like two sides of the same coin. They both sound like, “I don’t like what you are. You should be this way.”
“You can’t wait around for people to change.” This one sounds the closest to the truth to me. To me, it says, “People can change. People do change. But it’s not up to you to decide who and when.” It says, “You do your part, regardless. That’s all you can do. And it’s what you’re supposed to do.”
I believe, based on my faith, that if you’re married . . . you’re married. If you married a smoker, you married a smoker. I don’t think you can simply demand that person stop smoking if you decide you don’t like it. I do think it’s okay for you to say something like, “I’d love it if you didn’t smoke.” I’ve seen first-hand how that can create the desire to change in the heart of your spouse. They can and will decide to change all on their own. They won’t hold it against you (because it was their decision). But you can’t expect anything.
Yep. There’s the rub.
You can’t say “I’ve love it if you didn’t smoke” out loud, and to yourself say, “Okay, step one is complete. Now he has to stop smoking. Then I can be happy.” You can’t expect any action. You married a smoker. You had your choice. : P
You can pray for them. You can show them that you love them no matter what.
I’ll tell you what will make them want to smoke even more: telling/asking them to stop during this time, or even before/after.
I think there are two important issues here: conditional love and conviction.
Conviction first. Sorry, Hamlet, but I don’t think you can create conviction in someone else’s heart. I think you can inspire guilt, but I don’t think that’s very productive. Guilt is good for making someone angry, or depressed, or an alcoholic. They might end up the writer of the century, posthumously, of course, but I don’t think you’ll see great change come about in their life.
How does someone get to conviction, then? If you’re a Christian, like me, then I think the answer is The Holy Spirit, prayer, and counseling. If you’re not, then I think it’s something like intense introspection and counseling.
Conditional love: it’s for the birds. Actually, according to Matthew 6:26, even they seem to get unconditional love. Your spouse can’t think for a second that your love for them is contingent on them doing – or not doing – something right. As soon as they thing they’ve screwed that up, they’re prone to give up and give in to whatever is tempting them (cigarette, anger issues, voting for the wrong guy).
If you’re a Christian, how did God get you to change? He showed you love – love you knew you didn’t deserve, and love you knew you couldn’t earn if you tried. Did you change because of it? I know I did.
I also changed when I got married, God and my wife are both now loving me unconditionally. I have a LOT of changing yet to do.